Ishopanishad 7

यस्मिन्सर्वाणि भूतान्यात्मैवाभूद्विजानतः ।
तत्र को मोहः कः शोक एकत्वमनुपश्यतः ॥ ७ ॥

yasmin sarvANi bhUthAnyAthmaivAbhU dvijAnathah|
thathra ko mohah kah s’oka ekathva manupas’yathah||

पदविभाग

यस्मिन् सर्वाणि भूतानि आत्मा एव अभूत् विजानतः तत्र क: मोह: कः शोक एकत्वम् अनुपश्यतः

Meanings
yasmin = for which person, during the meditation
vijAnatah = having maturity in the knowledge of Brahman
Atmaiva = that Brahman
abhUth = is visualized (firmly)
sarvANi bhUtAni = as the form of all the entities
tatra = in that state of meditation
anupas’yathah = for the meditating seeker meditating on ekatvam = non-duality (qualified) of Brahman with all the entities
mohah kah s’okah kah= where is the sorrow or infatuation?

For a seeker who meditates that Brahman, who is visualized as the same Brahman appearing in every entity of this universe, there is neither sorrow nor infatuation.

Madhva commentary

“That Supreme Self, in whom are ail creatures, is indeed that same Supreme Self, who exists, and has existed within all creatures too (from eternity).” This is the Truth. He who knows this truth, and sees the Supreme Self thus residing in all creatures as a unity, can have no delusion. That Atman in whom are all-creatures, is all pervading and is inside of all beings. He who thus sees Viṣnu everywhere, has no delusion nor sorrow, for he has known the truth.”

That Supreme Self in whom stay all the beings, is the same Supreme Self who already was in those beings. As the support of all beings He exists in all beings from eternity. He who knows the Supreme Self thus—intellectually as well as by realisation—and also knows that though the beings are many, yet the Supreme Self in them is one,——and thus knows that the Lord is merciful and he, the devotee, is the object of His mercy——has no delusion and no grief. But how can this mere knowledge remove all grief, &c.? To this the commentator answers

“Since the knower of the Lord completely attains the Lord, hence takes place the cessation of all sorrow and delusion” thus says the Pippalāda Śruti. The last verse declared that the knower of Brahman becomes fearless; this verse makes an additional statement that such a knower has no delusion and sorrow.

Sri S’ankara has given the meanings for this Mantra as given below

  • vijAnathah = For him who knew the ultimate reality
  • yasmin = in which moment
  • Atmaiva = Brahman alone
  • abhUth = became
  • sarvabhUthAni = as all the entities encompassing from the avyakta
  • the indefinable to the fixed entities like mountains
  • thathra = at that moment itself
  • anupas’yathah = realizes, that
  • ekathvam = the reality of Atma is the Brahman
  • ko mohah = where is the infatuation
  • kas’s’okah = and where is the sorrow?
  • Thus S’ankara says that a person, who understands that the soul alone is the reality and the rest is all only illusory, and the cycle of births and deaths is all only an illusion, will not experience infatuations or sorrows arising out of ignorance at all.

Ishopanishad 6

यस्तु सर्वाणि भूतान्यात्मन्येवानुपश्यति ।
सर्वभूतेषु चात्मानं ततो न विजुगुप्सते ॥ ६ ॥

yasthu sarvANi bhUthAni AthmanyevAnupas’yathi|
sarvabhUtheshu chAthmAnam thatho na vijugupsathe||

पदविभाग

य: तु सर्वाणि भूतानि आत्मनि एव अनुपश्यति सर्वभूतेषु च आत्मानम् ततः न विजुगुप्सते

word meanings:
yastu = Whichever person having the knowledge of Brahman
anupas’yati = considers that
sarvANi bhUthAni = all entities
AtmanyevA = depend on the Brahman only
sarvabhUtheshu cha = and in all the entities
AtmAnam = Brahman is
anupas’yathi = seen as permeated

sah = that person having the knowledge of the Brahman
na vijugupsathe = will not have negative thinking
tatah = about those entities, which have Brahman as the soul

Whoever knows or considers that every entity starting from the four-faced Brahma to the static inanimate object in this universe is controlled by Brahman; and considers that since Brahman is present by his expansive power in all the entities to control and sustain them, all these entities have Brahman as their soul and is part of His domain, such a wise man – the brahmajnAni, will not consider any entity in this universe to be hate-worthy. He treats every entity as equal.

One starts to do sinful acts only after he turns to hate. As such it is very essential for the seeker to remove the hate from his mind. The hate towards other entities will be wiped out completely only when he starts to consider that every entity in the universe has Brahman as its soul.

This idea is the substance of this mantra. It appears as though the entire universe is in the Brahman and Brahman is in the universe. If that view is taken, it is faulty thinking due to the interdependency. So it should be considered that the universe is controlled by the Brahman, and Brahman enters every entity of the universe as the controller.

2. One who sees all animate and inanimate nature in the Supreme (for He exists outside them and is their support), and also sees the Supreme in all of them (for He exists in them, and is their controller from within), by this reason, he becomes free of fear and does not ever need to seek concealment.

One who perceives Sri Hari as being the sole independent entity and the motivator of all, has no fear of anyone, since he knows that all power belongs to the Lord only, not to any other.

3. Śaṅkarācārya explains the meaning of this mantra from the perspective of a Parivrājaka (परिव्राजक), a Sanyaasi who seeks liberation (Mumukṣu).

A renunciant who seeks liberation sees all beings and entities, from Avyakta (the unmanifest) to Sthāvara (immovable objects), as existing in the Ātman alone. He does not perceive anything as existing independently of the Ātman.

He also recognises the Ātman in all beings. This means that he sees the same Ātman as the inner Self of every entity.

Just as a person recognises the Self as the conscious witness of the body and its organs, the liberated seeker recognises that same Ātman as the Self of all beings.

This Ātman is:

  • Nirguṇa – free from attributes.
  • Kevala – pure and independent.
  • Chetayitā – the conscious principle.
  • Sākṣī – the witness of all thoughts and experiences.

The seeker realises that the very same Ātman, which is the witness and conscious principle in his own body, is also the Self of all beings, from the unmanifest to the immovable entities. He perceives no distinction in the essential nature of the Ātman.

One who sees the same pure, attribute-free Ātman in all beings and all beings in the Ātman does not develop hatred or aversion towards anything.

Ishopanishad 5

तदेजति तन्नैजति तद्दूरे तद्वन्तिके ।

तदन्तरस्य सर्वस्य तदु सर्वस्यास्य बाह्यतः ॥५॥

thadejathi thannaijathi – thaddUre thadvanthike|
thadantharasya sarvasya thadu sarvasyAsya bAhyathah||

पदविभाग

तत् एजति तत् न एजति तत् दूरे तत् उ अन्तिके तत् अन्तः अस्य तत् उ सर्वस्य अस्य  बाह्यतः

तदेजति तन्नैजति

  • Word Meanings –
  • tat = that Brahman (tasmaat -from him)
  • ejati = moves (vibheti or fears)
  • tat u = that Brahman again
  • na ejati = does not move

‘Tat’ refers to Parabrahman

‘ओं तत्सदिति निर्देशो ब्रह्मणस्त्रिविधः स्मृतः ।’ (BG 17.23)

किं यत्त्पदमनुत्तमम् ।( विष्णुसहस्त्रनाम श्लोक ६१ )

He moves, he doesn’t move.

How can the contradictory characteristics of moving but at the same time non-moving be there in the same Brahman?

The explanation is that Brahman is all-pervading. Like space, He is present everywhere and therefore does not need to move from one place to another to reach any destination. He is naturally present everywhere. At the same time, Brahman can manifest Himself in His Divya Maṅgala Vigraha at different places, even simultaneously, to bless and protect His devotees. To an observer, this may appear as though He has moved instantaneously from one place to another. Thus, although He is non-moving by His all-pervading nature, He manifests Himself wherever He wishes.

There is also another interpretation of the word Ejati. If it is understood as trembling or being moved, it can indicate that Bhagavān is deeply moved by compassion when He witnesses the suffering of His devotees. Conversely, He does not tremble before anyone, because there is no power superior to Him.

2. Dvaita :

Tatejati – every one fears Paramatama

Tat na ejati – Paramatma fears no one.

The words “tad ejat” do not mean either that Brahman is agitated or active Himself; or that He is afraid. In fack the word ‘tad’ is an indeclinable here, and means ‘from him’ or ‘on account of Him.’ we have to understand that the ‘Tat’ is an ‘Avyaya’. An Avyaya can be used in all the 7 cases. Here, the ‘Tat’ is Panchamyantam. So, we have to say ‘Tatejati’, which means, fear from HIM.

3. Advaita :

It’ means ‘the entity of the Atman which is being treated of.’ ’ The meaning is that though motionless in itself, it seems to move. It is naturally motionless and changeless, yet it appears to move.

तद्दूरे तद्वन्तिके

tat dUre = that (Brahman) is very far
tat u antike = that (Brahman) again is very near

In Vedic literature, उ means ‘eva’. So, ‘Tat u’ means, the same Paramatma.

‘तदेवाग्निस्तदादित्यस्तद्वायुस्तदु चन्द्रमाः।’ (श्वे० अ०४ श्रु०२)

For those who are indifferent towards Bhagavān and whose minds are constantly attached to worldly pleasures and activities, Brahman remains very difficult to realise. This idea is expressed by Sage Śaunaka in the following verse:

पराङ्मुखानां गोविन्दे विषयासक्तचेतसाम्।
तेषां तत्परमं ब्रह्म दूराद् दूरतरं स्थितम्॥

Meaning: For those who turn away from Govinda and whose minds remain attached to worldly objects and pleasures, the Supreme Brahman remains extremely distant and difficult to attain.

On the other hand, for those devotees who have completely surrendered their minds to Govinda, remain absorbed in His contemplation and have given up attachment to worldly pleasures, Brahman is easily approachable and very near.

Sage Śaunaka expresses this through another verse:

तन्मयत्वेन गोविन्दे ये नराः न्यस्तचेतसः।
विषयत्यागिनस्तेषां विज्ञेयं च तदन्तिके॥

Meaning: For those who have fixed their minds upon Govinda and become completely absorbed in Him, giving up attachment to worldly objects, the Supreme Brahman is very near and easily realised.

2. He is very far off (He exists even at infinite distances). Even Chaturmukha Brahma cannot fully know all the qualities of Paramatma.,

He is also very close by (because He is omnipresent).

3. it is distant, i.e., it seems to be far removed, because it is not attainable by the ignorant, even in the course of hundreds of millions of ages. Tadvantike is split into tad, u and antike. It is very near to the knowing; for, it is their Atman.

तदन्तरस्य सर्वस्य तदु सर्वस्यास्य बाह्यतः

  • tat u = that (Brahman) is
  • antah = inside
  • asya sarvasya = this entire universe
  • tat u = that (Brahman) again is
  • bAhyatah = outside
  • asya sarvasya = this entire universe

Some entities can permeate – have antharvyApthy, in some objects. There is no pervasion – bahirvyApthi for those entities. Similarly, some entities can pervade or cover some objects– have bahirvyApthi. There is no permeation for those entities. They can simply pervade those objects only and cannot have the antharvyApthy.

On the other hand, Brahman permeates and pervades every entity – all sentient and insentient, in universe – starting from the atomic entity to the vast universe – the BrahmANda. This is the extra-ordinary characteristic of the Brahman.

अन्तर्बहिश्च तत्सर्वं व्याप्य नारायणः स्थितः ॥ (महाना ० १३।२)

Q. A philosophical question arises here: How can Brahman pervade an extremely minute entity such as an atomic Jīva, which has no physical space within it? Similarly, how can Brahman pervade Ākāśa (space), Kāla (time) and other all-pervading entities that have no outer boundary or surface?

Ans: The answer is found in the Śruti description of Brahman as:

अणोरणीयान्

Brahman is subtler and smaller than the smallest entity. Therefore, His presence within an atomic Jīva is not restricted by the limitations that apply to other physical entities. Although there is no room within an atomic Jīva for other subtle material elements (Bhūtasūkṣmas) to enter, Brahman can nevertheless be present within it.

This can be understood through the example of a subtle form of fire entering a dense iron ball. Other physical entities may not be able to penetrate the iron ball, but fire can enter it and make the iron hot. Similarly, Brahman can be present within the atomic Jīva even though other subtle material entities cannot enter it.

The relationship between Brahman and the Jīva is also explained through the Śruti doctrine of Śarīra–Śarīribhāva (शरीर-शरीरिभाव), according to which the Jīva is the body and Brahman is its indwelling Self.

The following Śruti passage establishes this relationship:

य आत्मनि तिष्ठन्नात्मनोऽन्तरो यमात्मा न वेद। यस्यात्मा शरीरम्।

Even space, which is itself all-pervading, is included within Brahman’s pervasion because it forms part of His body.

अथवा बहुनैतेन किं ज्ञातेन तवार्जुन।
विष्टभ्याहमिदं कृत्स्नमेकांशेन स्थितो जगत्॥ (भगवद्गीता १०.४२ )

Meaning: O Arjuna! What is the need for knowing all these details? I sustain this entire universe by a single portion of Myself.

इहैकस्थं जगत्कृत्स्नं पश्याद्य सचराचरम्।
मम देहे गुडाकेश यच्चान्यद्द्रष्टुमिच्छसि॥ (भगवद्गीता ११.७)

Meaning: O Arjuna! Behold the entire universe, consisting of all moving and non-moving entities, together in one place within My body.

Ishopanishad 4

anejadekam manaso javeeyo nainaddevA Apnuvan pUrvamarshath|
thaddhAvathonyAnathyethi thishThaththasminnapo mAtharis’vA dadhAthi||

अनेजदेकं मनसो जवीयो नैनद्देवा आप्नुवन्पूर्वमर्षत् ।

तद्धावतोऽन्यानत्येति तिष्ठत्तस्मिन्नपो मातरिश्वादधाति॥४॥

पदविभाग

अनेजत् एकम् मनसः जवीयः न एनत् देवाः आप्नुवन् पूर्वम् अर्षत् तत् धावतः अन्यान् अत्येति तिष्ठति तस्मिन् अप: मातरिश्वा दधाति

Anejadekam manaso javeeyah (अनेजदेकं मनसो जवीय:)

Word Meanings

  • anejath = non-moving, not trembling, free of all fear
  • ekam = as being the principal, the supreme
  • manasah javeeyah = is extremely faster than even the mind can think of, swifter than mind
  1. Anejat is a compound of na and ejat. The root ejri means to shake. (एजृ कम्पने, कम्पनं चलनं स्वावस्थाप्रच्युतिः) Shaking is motion, i.e., deviation, from a fixed position. (The Supreme is) completely free of fear, for being the primary Being.

‘भीषास्माद्वातः पवते । भीषोदेति सूर्यः । भीषारमादग्निश्चेन्द्रश्च । मृत्युधार्वति पश्चमः ॥’ (तैत्तिरीय प० वल्ली २ अनुवाक ८)

न तत्समश्चाभ्यधिकश्च दृश्यते ।(श्वे० अ०६ श्रु०८)

2. Anejadekam manaso javeeyah (अनेजदेकं मनसो जवीय:) –the Brahman runs faster than the mind though He does not move.

How is this inconsistent statement made i. e., that it is constant and motionless and at the same time fleeter than the mind? This is no fault.

How can there be speed for an entity which is does not move? The answer for this question is – since Brahman, though does not move, permeated everything already, He is everywhere before anybody can even think of going there. Thus this statement that He is faster even than the mind is symbolic. In other words, He has the power to be available at a place which is very far away; on the very moment He proposes that a job is done at that place, in that form even the mind cannot think of. Hence He is faster than even the mind.

Although Brahman does not move from one place to another, He is already present everywhere. Therefore, He is present at a destination even before the mind can think of reaching it. In this sense, Brahman is described as being faster than the mind. The mind may take time to conceive of a distant place, but Brahman, being all-pervading, is already present there.

श्वेताश्वतरोपनिषत् ३.१९ : अपाणिपादो जवनो ग्रहीता, पश्यत्यचक्षुः स शृणोत्यकर्णः।

This passage explains that Brahman, although without physical hands and feet, can grasp and move swiftly. Although He has no physical eyes or ears, He can see and hear everything. His abilities are not limited by the absence of physical organs.

कठोपनिषत् १.२.२१ : आसीनो दूरं व्रजति शयानो याति सर्वतः।

This means that Brahman, even while seated, travels to distant places, and even while lying down, reaches everywhere. This does not indicate physical movement; rather, it establishes His all-pervading nature and extraordinary power.

3. Advaita : Śaṅkara resolves this apparent contradiction through the distinction between Nirupādhika and Sopādhika aspects of Brahman.

  • Nirupādhika refers to Brahman in His essential nature, without any limiting adjuncts. In this nature, He is absolutely changeless and motionless.
  • Sopādhika refers to Brahman as understood in association with limiting adjuncts (Upādhis).

The mind is an Upādhi associated with the individual body. A person sitting in one place can mentally conceive of a distant place, such as Brahmaloka, within a moment. Therefore, the mind is commonly regarded as extremely swift. However, even before the mind reaches its imagined destination, the consciousness of the Ātman is already present there. This is because Ātman is all-pervading, like space.

नैनद्देवा आप्नुवन्पूर्वमर्षत्

Word Meanings

  • devAh= the devatas like the four headed Brahma, Rudra etc or senses (as per Shankara) (द्योतनाद्देवाः चक्षुरादीनीन्द्रियाणि)
  • na Apnuvan = cannot know fully about or (these senses) could not overtake
  • enat = this paramathma, who was earlier mentioned
  • pUrvam arshat = even though He permeated everywhere already. or knowing from before, since beginningless time;

Even the great celestial beings, such as Brahmā and Rudra, cannot fully comprehend Brahman, although He is present everywhere and is very close to all beings. The reason is that Brahman possesses infinite attributes and immeasurable greatness, whereas the knowledge of individual beings is limited by their own inherent limitations and cosmic bondage. Therefore, even highly knowledgeable beings cannot completely comprehend the infinite nature of Brahman. This idea is illustrated through an example in the Chāndogya Upaniṣad:

तद्यथा हिरण्यनिधिं निहितमक्षेत्रज्ञा उपर्युपरि सञ्चरन्तो न विन्देयुः।

एवमेवेमाः सर्वाः प्रजा अहरहर्गच्छन्त्य एतं ब्रह्मलोकं न विन्दन्त्यनृतेन हि प्रत्यूढाः॥ (छान्दोग्योपनिषत् 8.3.1)

“Suppose a valuable treasure of gold is buried beneath the ground in a particular place. People who do not know how to identify the treasure may continuously walk over that very place without discovering it. Although the treasure is extremely close to them, they remain unaware of its existence.”

In the same way, all living beings pass through their daily activities without recognising Brahman, who is present within them and everywhere around them. Their inability to recognise Him is due to their ignorance and bondage to worldly existence. The same principle is expressed in the Śruti through the following passage:

बृहदारण्यकोपनिषत् ३.७.३ : यः पृथिव्यां तिष्ठन् पृथिव्या अन्तरो यं पृथिवी न वेद। यस्य पृथिवी शरीरं यः पृथिवीमन्तरो यमयति।

2. Dvaita : ‘The devas even cannot reach Him’ means that they are even incapable of fully and completely understanding Him. By His very nature, He knows everything from before the beginning of time. The Devas do not fully know Him, but He knows them all from eternity.

न मे विदुः सुरगणाः प्रभवं न महर्षयः।
अहमादिर्हि देवानां महर्षीणां च सर्वशः॥ भगवद्गीता १०.२॥

हूनि मे व्यतीतानि जन्मानि तव चार्जुन।
तान्यहं वेद सर्वाणि न त्वं वेत्थ परन्तप॥ भगवद्गीता ४.५ ॥

3. Advaita : Devas, from the root द्योतनाद्देवाः which means ‘enlighten,’ signifies the senses such as the eye, etc. Etat means the entity of the Atman which is now being treated of. These senses could not overtake it. The mind is faster than these, for they are distanced by the activity of the mind. Not even the semblance of the Atman is within the perception of the senses; for it had gone even before the mind, which is fleeter than they, being all-pervading, like the Akas.

Thus, neither the sense organs nor the mind can comprehend the true nature of the Ātman.

तद्धावतोऽन्यानत्येति तिष्ठत्

  • Word Meanings
  • tat = That ParamAtma
  • thishThat = though is staying firm
  • atyeti = can surpass them
  • dhAvatah anyAn = the others running speedily

Brahman remains beyond the reach of even the fastest-moving beings. Although He is all-pervading and does not move, He is beyond the reach of those who attempt to approach or measure His greatness through their speed or power. Even Garuḍa, the king of birds, who is renowned for his extraordinary speed, cannot reach the limits of Brahman’s greatness. This idea is illustrated by the following verse:

वर्षायुतशतैर्वापि पक्षिराडिव सम्पतन्। नैवान्तं कारणस्येयाद् यद्यपि स्यान्मनोजवः॥

Meaning: Even if someone travels continuously for hundreds of thousands of years, moving as swiftly as Garuḍa or possessing the speed of the mind, he cannot reach the end or boundary of Brahman, who is the ultimate cause of the entire universe.

The substance shows that Brahman is so great that the greatness has no boundaries.

Om, Tat & Sat are the special names of Paramatma.

ॐ तत्सदिति निर्देशो ब्रह्मणस्त्रिविध: स्मृत: ।
ब्राह्मणास्तेन
वेदाश्च यज्ञाश्च विहिता: पुरा ॥ BG 17.23॥

किं यत्त्पदमनुत्तमम् ।( विष्णुसहस्त्रनाम श्लोक ६१ )

2. Dvaita : Though all may be straining their utmost to catch Him and be running after Him, yet He by merely staying in one place is beyond their reach.

3. Advaita: The entity of the Atman, all-pervading, devoid of any attributes of samsara, and in its unconditioned state subject to no modification, appears to undergo all the changes of samsara. superposed upon it. and though one, appears, in the eyes of ignorant men, diverse and enclosed in every body. It seems to travel beyond the reach of others’ mind, speech, the senses, &c., which are dissimilar to the Atman, though they run fast.

तस्मिन्नपो मातरिश्वादधाति

Word Meanings

  • mAtaris’vA = the Vayu – the air, mukya praana
  • tasmin = depending upon that Paramatman
  • dadhAthi = is holding
  • apah = the water, karma.

All the elements and celestial bodies in the universe are sustained by Brahman, who is their ultimate support.

The air (Vāyu) moves freely through space (Ākāśa), which itself has no visible physical support. It carries and sustains clouds, water and other elements. Similarly, the planets, stars and other celestial bodies remain in their respective positions without collapsing or coming together. However, air itself does not possess the independent power to sustain all these entities. Its ability to support and maintain them comes from Brahman, who is the ultimate and unseen support of everything.

This can be understood through a simple example. Consider the statement:

Prāsādaśikhare Caitro dhvajaṃ dhārayati — Caitra, standing on the rooftop of a building, holds a flag.

Although Caitra is directly holding the flag, he is himself supported by the building. Thus, the building indirectly supports the flag by supporting the person who holds it. In the same way, although Vāyu appears to sustain water, clouds and other celestial entities, Vāyu itself is sustained by Brahman.

द्यौः सचन्द्रार्कनक्षत्रं खं दिशो भूर्महोदधिः। वासुदेवस्य वीर्येण विधृतानि महात्मनः॥ (Mahabharatam)

एतस्य वा अक्षरस्य प्रशासने गार्गि सूर्याचन्द्रमसौ विधृतौ तिष्ठतः। (Bṛhadāraṇyaka Upaniṣad ३.८.९)

2. Dvaita: Mukhya Prana/Vayu deva dedicates all the actions performed by all creatures. When a person does an act with perfect humility, believing that the true agent is Hari and not he, that all acts are sacred and must be performed with the idea of their being sacred, and with full love and devotion towards God, such acts become holy and are carried by Vāyu to the Lord. Since the man has renounced all fruits of action and does all act for the Lord, they remain in Him. This of course refers to karmas of good men.

3. Advaita: All worldly activities and transformations depend upon the eternal consciousness of the Ātman, while the Ātman itself remains unchanged. Matarisva means air. This air supports the fire, sun, rain, etc. Apas means all Karmas or actions. Water stands for acts, because all sacrificial acts are performed with water. The word Dadhāti means either Vibhajati (assigns their respective functions) or Dhārayati (sustains them).

पञ्च-भूतों एवं 11 इन्द्रियों का सम्बन्ध, भूतों के गुण

अब हम पंच-भूतों एवं 11 इन्द्रियों के सम्बन्ध के बारे में पढ़ेंगे। सभी भूतों में कौन कौन से गुण हैं एवं उनके विषय क्या हैं।

अबतक हम सात्विक अहंकार से पञ्च-ज्ञानेन्द्रिय, पंच-कर्मेन्द्रिय और मन की उत्पत्ति एवं तामसिक अहंकार से पंच-तन्मात्र एवं पंच-भूतों की उत्पत्ति पढ़ चुके हैं।

नैयायिकों के मत में इन्द्रिय भूतों से ही उत्पन्न होते हैं अर्थात इन्द्रिय भौतिक पदार्थ हैं। किन्तु ऐसा कहना शास्त्र-सम्मत नहीं है। विष्णु-पुराण की व्याख्या में विष्णुचित्त स्वामी सप्रमाण खण्डन करते हैं। इन्द्रियों को भौतिक इस कारण कहा गया है क्योंकि भूत इन्द्रियों के आप्यायक (पोषक) हैं। एवं ज्ञान-इन्द्रियों की उत्पत्ति में तन्मात्र सहायक होते हैं। कर्म-इन्द्रियों की उत्पत्ति में ज्ञान-इन्द्रिय सहायक होते हैं।

तन्मात्र के सहयोग से ज्ञानेन्द्रियों की उत्पत्ति

शब्द तन्मात्र के सहयोग से श्रोत्र इन्द्रिय, स्पर्श तन्मात्र के सहयोग से त्वग इन्द्रिय, रूप तन्मात्र के सहयोग से चक्षु इन्द्रिय, रस तन्मात्र के सहयोग से रसन इन्द्रिय एवं गन्ध तन्मात्र के सहयोग से घ्राण इन्द्रिय की उत्पत्ति होती है। पूर्व में पढ़ चुके हैं कि इन्द्रिय अणु एवं सूक्ष्म होते हैं। श्रोत्र का निवास कर्ण में, त्वग का निवास पूरे शरीर में, चक्षु का निवास आंखों के कृष्ण-तारा में, रसन का निवास जिह्वा में एवं घ्राण का निवास नासिका में। इस प्रकार प्रत्येक इन्द्रिय शरीर के किसी विशेष अंग के अग्र भाग में निवास करते हैं।

ज्ञानेन्द्रियों के सहकार से कर्मेन्द्रियों की उत्पत्ति।

श्रोत्र इन्द्रिय के सहकार से वाणी कर्मेन्द्रिय की उत्पत्ति होती है। त्वग से पाणी (हस्त) कर्मेन्द्रिय, चक्षु से पाद (पैर) कर्मेन्द्रिय, रसन से उपस्थ (मूत्र-विसर्जन कर्मेन्द्रिय) एवं घ्राण के सहकार से पायू (मल-कर्मेन्द्रिय)।

भूतों के गुण

आकाश का एकमात्र विशेष गुण है शब्द।

वायु में स्पर्श के साथ शब्द (क्योंकि वो आकाश से उत्पन्न है और उसमें आकाश का भी गुण है।)

अग्नि में रूप के साथ शब्द और स्पर्श। (क्योंकि वो वायु से उत्पन्न है और उसमें वायु का भी गुण है।)

जल में रस के साथ शब्द, स्पर्श और रूप। (क्योंकि वो अग्नि से उत्पन्न है और उसमें अग्नि का भी गुण है।)

पृथ्वी में गन्ध के साथ शब्द, स्पर्श, रूप और रस। (क्योंकि वो जल से उत्पन्न है और उसमें जल का भी गुण है।)

इस प्रकार, पृथ्वी में सभी 5 गुण हैं। गन्ध गुण केवल पृथ्वी में है। शब्द गुण सभी पाँच भूतों में है।

भूतगुण
आकाशशब्द
वायुशब्द, स्पर्श
तेजस (अग्नि)शब्द, स्पर्श, रूप
आप: (जल)शब्द, स्पर्श, रूप, रस
पृथ्वी (भूमि)शब्द, स्पर्श, रूप, रस, गन्ध

भूत एवं उनके विषय

सभी भूतों के विषय भी chart में दिए गए हैं। आकाश विभू है (अहंकार, महत एवं प्रकृति में व्याप्त नहीं है), सर्वत्र व्याप्त है। आकाश का संयोग सभी मूर्त द्रव्यों से है। पृथ्वी का विषय मिट्टी, पत्थर आदि है। जल का विषय सरित, समुद्र आदि। अग्नि/तेजस का विषय वह्नि, विद्युत, सुवर्ण, रजत आदि हैं। इन सभी विषयों में हम भूतों के गुणों को समझ सकते हैं।

पदार्थ विभाग भाग 1: प्रकृति से महत एवं महत से अहंकार एवं सात्त्विक अहंकार से 11 इन्द्रियों की उत्पत्ति

पदार्थ शब्द का अर्थ क्या है? पदस्य अर्थ: पदार्थ:। इस प्रकार पदार्थ अर्थात तत्त्व।

पदार्थ के दो प्रकार हैं: द्रव्य और अद्रव्य।

अद्रव्य की चर्चा बाद में करते हैं। द्रव्य वो हैं जो गुण या क्रिया का आश्रय हैं। जो अवस्थान्तर को प्राप्त होते हैं।

द्रव्य के दो प्रकार हैं: चित और अचित। चित अर्थात चैतन्य का आश्रय द्रव्य। जिसमें चैतन्य अर्थात ज्ञान हो। अचित अर्थात चैतन्य का अनाश्रय द्रव्य। जिसमें चैतन्य अर्थात ज्ञान न हो।

चित दो प्रकार के हैं: जीवात्मा और परमात्मा।

अचित तीन प्रकार के हैं: प्रकृति (मिश्र सत्त्व), काल और शुद्ध-सत्त्व।
प्रकृति भगवान का लीला उपकरण है।

मिश्र सत्त्व कुल मिलाकर 24 तत्त्व हैं। बाकि 23 तत्त्व प्रकृति के ही विकार हैं। प्रकृति अर्थात मूल/ उपादान कारण। इसी को अविद्या और माया भी कहते हैं। मूल प्रकृति तक सम सृष्टि है। सत्त्व, रजस एवं तमस समान मात्रा में होने के कारण अनुद्भूत होते हैं।

प्रकृति के बाद की सृष्टि विषम सृष्टि हैं। सत्त्व, रजस एवं तमस विषम मात्रा में होने के कारण उद्भूत अवस्था में होते हैं।

प्रकृति से उत्पन्न है महान, जो सात्त्विक, राजसिक एवं तामसिक 3 प्रकार का होता है। महान को ही बुद्धि भी कहते हैं। महान से उत्पन्न होता है सात्त्विक, राजसिक एवं तामसिक अहंकार। ये अहंकार तत्त्व ही अभिमान का हेतु है।

सात्त्विक अहंकार से उत्पन्न होते हैं 11 इन्द्रिय। ये दो प्रकार के हैं: ज्ञानेन्द्रिय एवं कर्मेन्द्रिय।

ज्ञानेन्द्रिय 6 हैं: 5 बाह्य ज्ञानेन्द्रिय एवं 1 आन्तर ज्ञानेन्द्रिय अर्थात मन या अंतःकरण। 5 बाह्य ज्ञानेन्द्रिय हैं: घ्राण (सूंघने का इन्द्रिय), रसन (स्वाद का इन्द्रिय), चक्षु (देखने का इन्द्रिय), त्वक् (स्पर्श का इन्द्रिय), श्रोत्र (श्रवण का इन्द्रिय)। ये क्रमशः गन्ध, रस, रूप, स्पर्श एवं शब्द के ग्राहक हैं। (इन्द्रिय अत्यन्त सूक्ष्म होते हैं, इन्हें शरीर के अंग नासिका, आँख आदि न समझें| अपितु इन्द्रिय शरीर अंगों के अग्र भाग में रहते हैं)|

5 कर्मेन्द्रिय हैं: वाक्, पाणि, पाद, पायू (मूत्र विसर्जनका इन्द्रिय) एवं उपस्थ (मल विसर्जन का इन्द्रिय)। ये क्रमशः वचन, आदान, गमन, विसर्जन एवं आनन्द के हेतु हैं।

तामस अहंकार से 5 तन्मात्र एवं 5 भूत उत्पन्न होते हैं।

राजस अहंकार दोनों के कार्य में सहकारी होता है।

Vyuha roopa of Bhagwan

For the purpose of creation, sustenance and destruction of the leela vibhuti, Bhagwan comes out of Paramapadam and resides in Vyuha lokam in each Andam. For these 3 purposes, bhagwan takes 3 forms: Sankarshana, Pradyumna and Aniruddha.

चतुर्विधः स भगवान् मुमुक्षूणां हिताय वै ।
अन्येषामपि लोकानां सृष्टिस्थित्यन्तसिद्धये ।।
आनन्त्यात्तव सेनाने व्यूह आद्यो मयेरितः ।
अनादिकर्मवश्यानां संसारे पततामधः ।। (Vishwaksen Samhita)

For the welfare of mumukshus (those desirous of moksha) and for the purpose of creation, protection and deluge, bhagwan becomes four-fold in Vyuha forms, as he is Ananta (infinite).

While Para Vasudeva shows all the 6 shad-gunas, the three Vyuha rupams show two gunams each, which are required for the specific tasks. Sometimes, Vyuha Vasudeva is also taken into Vyuha forms, and thus, the number of Vyuha forms is counted as four. However, Vyuha Vasudeva is not different from Para Vasudeva. He also shows all the 6 gunas and has no role in creation, sustenance and destruction. Since the same set of gunas are meditated in both Para Vasudeva and Vyuha Vasudeva, they are taken as one single Vasudeva moorti, and Vyuha forms are understood as three: Sankarshana, Pradyumna, and Aniruddha.

Sankarsha shows gyaana and bala. Pradyumna shows Aishwarya and Veerya, and Aniruddha shows Shakti and Tejas. The colour of sankarsha is like fresh gold, Pradyumna is like Indra Neelamani and Aniruddha is like Taatkaalika-megha.

It is to be noted that Bhagwan is always purna in shad-gunas in all his forms. However, some of the gunas are shown in particular forms, and some remain hidden.

Shad-gunas of Bhagwan

सत्त्वादयो न सन्तीशे यत्र च प्राकृता गुणाः ।
ज्ञानशक्तिबलैश्वर्य्यवीर्य्यतेजांस्यशेषतः
भगवच्छब्दवाच्यानि बिना हेयैर्गुणादिभिः ।। (Vishnu Puran 1-9-4)

Bhagwan has no praakrita/material gunas like sattva, rajas and tamas. On the other hand, he has kalyaan gunas like Gyaan, Shakti, Bala, Aishwarya, Veerya and Tejas. Being Bhagwan means having all these gunams in purnata and lack of heya (evil) gunas.

Gyaan, Shakti, Bala, Aishwarya, Veerya and Teja are the shad-gunas of Bhagwan. Vatsalya, Mardav etc. – all other swarupa-gunas come from these shad-gunas only.

Gyaana: Gyaanam is knowing about our karmas. Karmas are recorded in the dharmabhoota gyaana of Bhagwan. When creation happens, he provides names and forms as per our previous karma. He ensures that everyone gets fruits of their karma. Once someone surrenders, he simply deletes all his karmas from his gyaana.

Shakti: aghatit-ghatana-saamarthyam. Elevating a sansaari jeeva from this Samsara to Sri Vaikutham is the Shakti guna of Bhagwan.

Bala: बलं धारणसामर्थ्यम्। Bhagwan is holding the entire creation and yet he doesn’t get any tiredness. That is his Balam.

Aishwarya : समस्तवस्तुनियमन-सामर्थ्यम्। The bhaava of Ishwara is Aishwaryam. Bhagwan is controlling the entire creation, that is his aishwaryam.

Veerya : जगद-उपादानत्वे अपि स्वरूप-विकार-अभाव-रूप:। Though Bhagwan is the upaadan-kaaranam or material cause of the creation, just like mud is the material cause for the pot; he doesn’t get any deformation in his swarupa. This quality is Veerya.

Tejas : सहकारि-अनपेक्षा वा पराभिभवन सामर्थ्यम्। Bhagwan doesn’t need any Sahakari-kaaranam or helping cause just like a wheel is for pot in the creation. This quality is Tejas. Or Dominating the foes is called Tejas.

1. Bhagwan Sankarshana

भगवानच्युतोऽपीत्थं षड्गुणेन समेधितः ।

बलज्ञानगुणौ तस्य स्फुटौ कार्यवशान्मुने ।।

Though Bhagwan Achyuta (who never falls from his Shad-guna-purnya avastha) is qualified with all the 6 gunas, Gyaana and Bala erupt or appear in Bhagwan Sankarshana.

The works of Sankarshana are:

1. Jeeva-tattva-adhisthanam (using balam): In the deluge stage, entire mishra sattva dissolves into Mool Prakriti, and Mool Prakriti gets into the stage of tamas. Jeevatmas and mishra sattva get almost non-existent and can’t be distinguished from Ishwara. Jeevatmas are lying as if they don’t exist, without name and form, since mool prakriti itself has attained the stage of avyakta.

Bhagwan Sankarshana makes jeevatmas distinguished from Avyakta prakriti and starts the process of creation from avyakta to mool prakriti.

सङ्कर्षणस्तु देवेशो जगत्त्रष्टुमनास्ततः ।

जीवतत्त्वमधिष्ठाय प्रकृतेस्तु विविच्य तत् ।।

2. Shastra pravartanam (using gyaana): Preaches Shastras, especially Pancharatra vishesha shastra.

सोऽयं प्रद्युम्ननामा भूत्तदेकान्तवपुर्धरः

इति चोक्तप्रकारेण प्रद्युम्नावस्थां प्राप्य ।।

शास्त्रप्रवर्त्तनं चापि संहारं चैव देहिनाम् ।

बलेन हरतीदं स गुणेन निखिलं मुने ।।

ज्ञानेन तनुते शास्त्रं सर्वसिद्धान्तगोचरम् ।

वेदशास्त्रमिति ख्यातं पञ्चरात्रं विशेषतः ।

3. Sanhaar (using balam): Destroys the entire creation. Destroys Vyashti shrishti as antaryaami of Rudra, Kaala, etc., and destroys Samashti shrishti directly.

2. Bhagwan Pradyumna

ऐश्वर्य्यवीर्य्यसम्भेदाद्रूपं प्रद्युम्नमुच्यते ।

पूर्णषड्गुण एवायमच्युतोऽपि महामुने

गुणावैश्वर्यवीर्याख्यौ स्फुटौ तस्य विशेषतः ।।

Bhagwan Sankarsha has all the 6 gunas but Aishwarya and Veerya erupt/appear in him.

Bhagwan Sankarshana is the adhishtatri devata for Manas. (मत्तः स्मृतिर्ज्ञानमपोहनं च।)

मनसोऽयमधिष्ठाता, मनोमय इतीरितः ।

The works of Bhagwan Pradyumna are:

1. Creation of chara and achara in the Samsara (using Aishwarya gunam).

ऐश्वर्येण गुणेनासौ सृजते तच्चराचरम् ।

वीर्येण सर्वधर्माणि प्रवर्त्तयति सर्वशः ।।

There are two things to be noted here:

A. Creation by Pradyumna is Sadwaraka i.e. using the medium or dwara of Brahma, being his antaryami. Adwarak Srishti or Samasti srishti is done by Bhagwan Vasudeva itself. He creates Andas from his Sankalpa. Then he descends in each Andas in Vyuha loka as Sankarshana, Pradyumna and Aniruddha.

B. The creation work of Pradyumna is different from the creation work of Aniruddha.

Pradyumna carries out Shuddha-varga shrishti. He creates sattvika jeevas who are desirous of moksha, worships him alone through the dwaadashaakshar mantra and attains Bhagwan at the end.

मनूनां सर्गमकरोन्मुखबाहूरुपादतः

चतुर्णां ब्राह्मणादीनां सर्गद्वारं जगत्पतिः

2. Does dharma-pravartanam use veerya gunam.

3. Bhagwan Aniruddh

शक्तितेजः समुत्कर्षादनिरुद्धतनुर्हरि: ।

पुरुषोपि महाध्यक्षः पूर्णषाड्गुण्य उच्यते ।

शक्तितेजोगुणौ तस्य स्फुटौ कार्य्यवशान्मुने ।।

Bhagwan Aniruddha has Shakti and Tejas gunam.

The works of Bhagwan Aniruddha are:

1. Creation of jagat using Shakti.

It is to be understood here that Aniruddha does Shrishti of jeevatmas full of rajas and tamas. Shuddh-varga shrishti has already been told earlier as the work of Pradyumna. Mishra varga shrishti is done by Aniruddha using dwaara of Brahma (not directly).

Creation of Brahma is also done by Aniruddha only.

तुरीयोऽयं जगन्नाथो ब्रह्माणमसृजत्पुनः

मुखबाहूरुपज्जातो ब्रह्मणः परमेष्ठिनः ।।

2. Jagad-rakshanam using Shakti. (He eventually gives Rakshana kaaryam to Vishwaksena.)

3. Creation of kaala

4. Gives tattva-gyaana using Tejas gunam.

शक्त्या जगदिदं सर्वमनन्ताण्डन्निरन्तरम्

बिभर्ति पाति च हरिर्मणिसानुरिवाणुकम् ।

तेजसा निखिलं तत्त्वं ज्ञापयत्यात्मनो मुने ।।

Upa-Vyuhas

Earlier we studied about Sankarshana, Pradyumna and Aniruddha Vyuha roopams of Bhagwan.

Actually, the Vyuha forms are also infinite. From the 4 vyuha, comes 12 upa-vyuhas and from them comes 36 more. Keshava, Narayana and Maadhava come from Vasudeva. Govind, Vishnu and Madhusudana come from Sankarshana. Trivikrama, Vaamana and Shridhara come from Pradyumna. Hrishikesh, Padmanaabha and Damodara come from Aniruddha. These 12 Vyuhas reside at the 12 places in our bodies. From these 12 vyuhas, Padmanaabha, Dhruva, Ananata etc 36 Vyuhas come. The number of Vyuhas is thus infinite. The entire upasana of Paancharaatrikas revolves around Vyuha roopams.

LOCATION OF VYUHA LOKA

When Bhagwan creates the Andam and 14 lokas inside it, he himself comes to reside in Bhu lokam. Bhu Loka has 7 dweepas including Shweta dweepa and Jambu dwipa. It has 7 oceans including Ksheera ocean and Lavana ocean. The Vyuha lokam of Bhagwan is in the Ksheera ocean. Devas, Rudra and Brahma approach Vishnu at Shweta dweepa, where he gives them darshanam.

From the Vyuha loka in the Bhu loka, Lotus emerges from the navel of Vishnu and reaches Satya Loka. At the lotus there, Brahma takes birth. From Brahma, Rudra takes birth.

At Satyaloka, Vishnu again takes a form and resides with Rudra and Brahma as Trimurti Vishnu. In Satyaloka, there are separate Vishnu Loka, Rudra Loka and Brahma loka. These lokas are attained by their upaasakas. We have studied about the Shuddha-varga shrishti done by Pradyumna. Only those upaasakas have access to Vishnu Loka inside the Satya Loka.

In Srimad Bhagwatam, we came through an incident of 4 kumaras visiting Vishnu Loka and cursing Jaya Vijaya there. It is to be noted that Vishnu Loka is not Sri Vaikuntham but very much outside the Viraja river and exists in each Andam. The Jaya and Vijaya there are also not Nitya Suris.

MAYAVADI’S CRITICISM

Mayavaadis objects at the evolution of one vyuha from the previous Vyuha (Like ‘Sankarshana is born from Vasudeva’ etc).

However, their objections have no ground. It is their inability to understand Paancharatra. Bhagwan is not getting transformed into another form and his nirvikaaratvam is not harmed here. Bhagwan is very much the same. The change occurs only in his mangal Vigraha.

Pancharatra itself tells that it is like a deepam getting lighted from previous deepam. That’s how Bhagwan gets a new body. Aatma remains unchanged as he is vibhu (omnipresent)

ARE THERE THREE TYPES OF VISHNU?

Some people have this misconception. Vishnu is one only. Be is infinite Vyuha forms or infinite Vibhava forms, it’s only the change of body shapes for Vishnu. Bhagwan doesn’t change. But this is true, different gunas are experienced in different forms. However, he is complete with all the gunas in all the forms.

“Vishnu tu trini rupani” refers to 3 Vyuha forms in Pancharatra and not three different types of Vishnus.

Ramanuja-mata-saara-sangrah part 11

‘yathaartham sarva vigyaanam’ (yathaartha khyaati)

In VA vedaanta, there is no place for mithya. Every gyaanam is yathaartha or as-it-is and thus true.

1. Now, the question raised would be: is bhrama (illusion) also satya? Like Seashell is mistook as silver due to it’s shine. Is that also true?

Yes. That is also true. We have already studied panchikaranam. After Panchikaranam, all the bhootas have proportions of all the other bhootas as well. The rajat is already present in a seashell due to panchikaranam. Due to some upaadhis (like sunrays), the parts of tejas silver tattva are seen, and the parts of prithvi seashell aren’t seen.

What we have seen is true only since silver is undoubtedly present there. But since, the rajat is available in very small quantity after panchikaranam, Vyavhaara isn’t possible.

2. What about water seen in the desert? Is that also true? If that’s true, why can’t we drink that and remove thirst?

The water seen due to illusion is also true since water is present in prithvi, as a result of panchikaranam. Due to upaadhi, like the refraction of light or the shine of sunrays, etc., the water is seen there.

Why is water not always seen in Prithvi? It is because upaadhi is not always present. Whenever upaadhi is present, water is visible in prithvi. But since it is present in extremely small amounts, vyavhaara of water i.e. drinking and removing thirst is not possible.

3. The rope is misunderstood as a snake at night. Is that also true?

Yes, that is also true. The gyaana that was observed is true. The shape of the rope is similar to a snake. The attributes of the rope which are different from the snake were not observed due to darkness. Thus, there is a lack of observation in some parts.

If it was false, then why wasn’t there an illusion of an elephant for a rope? Moreover, the rope was visible as a lying snake only. Did anyone see it lifting its hood or moving like a snake? The gyaana which is obtained from limited observation, i.e., qualities of rope similar to snake, was not false but true only. Once light is thrown, we get the complete observation and illusion vanishes.

Conclusion

The bhrama, or illusion, is also yathaartha gyaana.

Note:

Swapna is also true, not an illusion. Paramaatma creates momentary objects for the anubhavam of that jeevatma only and for that time only, as per their karma. Thus, swapna gyaana is also to experience the karma of a jeevatma.

Lot of concepts are here to be understood like akhyaati, anyatha khyaathi, anirvachaniya khyaati etc. These are not in the scope of this book.

However, to note, we have yathaarth khyaati in VA.

Anga of Krishna: Narayana (SB 10.14.14)

shloka that is often referred and misinterpreted it:
नारायणस्त्वं न हि सर्वदेहिना-
मात्मास्यधीशाखिललोकसाक्षी ।
नारायणोऽङ्गं नरभूजलायना-
त्तच्चापि सत्यं न तवैव माया ॥ १४ ॥

Multiple commentaries are available here: https://archive.org/details/srimad-bhagavata-multiple-commentaries/sb_canto_10/page/n1481/mode/1up?view=theater

Brahma, who earlier received gyaanam from Bhagwan and who protected Vedas and gave gyaanam again to him, got deluded and considered Krishna as some ordinary child. He decided to test him and in turn repents in these shlokas:

Naarayanah na hi tvam? : Are you not NarayaNa? (Meaning, you are Narayana only. It is stressed here)

How,
1. sarvadehinaam aatma asi: Bhagwaam is antaryaami aatma of every jeevatma.

Naara means sarva dehi i.e. all jeevatmaas.
Naaraanaam ayanam NarayaNa i.e. one who is the ayana (support, means, destination) of all jeevatmas. The word ‘ayana’ comes from iN gatau dhaatu which gives several meanings to the word ayana.

Bhagwaan, being the antaryaami aatma of all, supports, owns, and holds them, and thus all the jeevatmas, being his body, are subservient to and dependent on Narayana.

2. Adheesh: Bhagwaan is the controller or pravartaka of everyone. He himself says in Bhagwan Gita “matah sarvam pravartate”

3. Akhil loka sakshi: Bhagwaan being antaryaami of every jeevatmas, is the drastha of our every activity. (iN gatau is gatyarthaka dhaatu and from ‘gatyarthah budhyarthah’ nyaaya, the word ayana would mean “sakshi”

and thus, you are NarayaNa (Naaraanaam ayanam). Meaning there is abheda (no difference) between Narayana and you.

How?
Here he quotes another meaning of the word NarayaNa which is quoted by Krishna himself in Mahabharata and also quoted in Manusmriti:

“आपो नारा इति प्रोक्ता आपो वै नरसूनवः । ता यदस्यायनं पूर्वं तेन नारायणः स्मृतः ॥

Nara refers to Bhagwaan as per Vishnu Sahasranaama (Jahnu NarayaNo Narah). From him is born waters. That was the ayanam (residing place) of Bhagwaan (and thus he is called ‘Narabhujala-ayanah’) as Vishnu (in Aniruddha vyuha form) or as Vatapatra-shaayi Krishna, who gave darshana to Markandeya. Since, Brahma here is joyous to see the Bhagwaan’s form, who had given him gyaanam; the apt meaning here is Vishnu.

Brahma had received gyaanam but he wasn’t able to see him. The story is dealt in detail earlier in Bhagwatam. Now, he is able to see him and his saying, “Are you not the Narayana, who lives on the Ksheera ocean waters?”

*नारायणोऽङ्गं नरभूजलायनात्तच्चापि सत्यं न तवैव माया ॥*

Vidwans like Sridhara swami, Sudarshana Suri, Shrinivaas suri, Sri Shukadeva and Goswami Giridhara laal etc have interpreted the word ‘anga’ as ‘murti’ or ‘vapu’.

The Narayana, lying on the waters is also your form only i.e. you are the same Narayana who gave me knowledge.

It is to be understood here that Bhagwaan as his aatma-swarupa is omnipresent. He is all-pervading, present everywhere. Bhagwaan also takes an asaadhaaran-mangal-vigraha or body to appear to us like Vishnu, Krishna, Rama etc. In Vishishtadvaita siddhanta, Bhagwaan is different from his body. Bhagwaan takes several bodies but that doesn’t make them different as the aatma is same. The shape of the body only differs. What is the asaadhaarana lakshana of his body? It’s the presence of Mahalakshmi on his chest in the form of Sri Vatsa Chinha. In Ramayanam and Mahabharatam, Valmiki and Vyaasa addresses bhagwaan as one having Mahalakshmi on his chest. Meaning, he is the Bhagwaan, Sarveshwara, Narayana.

Veer Raghavacharya swami quotes a nyaaya here

“Raho: shira iti vat tavaiva angam iti abheda sambandhe shashthi”. There is a popular nyaaya “Rahoh shiram”

“the head of Rahu”. What does this mean? The head itself is Rahu. Isn’t it? What does it mean to say the “head of Rahu”? It means ‘NON-DIFFERENCE’

Thus, ‘Narayanah angam tavaiva’ here would mean that ‘YOU ARE NON-DIFFERENT FROM NARAYANA’

Bhagwatprasaadaacharya also gives the same meaning, quoting, “raho: shir itivat tava angam iti abheda sambandhe shashthi. soapi tvameva ityarthah”

त्तच्चापि सत्यं न माया : That form/murti is satya and not maayaa.

Also, it’s important to read the shloka, along with the upcoming two shlokas, 15 and 16, failing to which people misinterpret the meanings, which goes contrary to the context.

The compassionate Bhagwan and unreciprocating Jeevatma (part 2)

In the previous part (https://ramanujramprapnna.blog/2024/03/17/the-unlimiting-compassion-of-bhagwan/), we discussed the efforts of Bhagwan to get the jeevatmas to attain him out of his compassion, and for this purpose, Bhagwan has been creating the samsara (to provide jeevatmas body, senses, etc. so that they can attain bhagwan) and dissolving them (so as to break the vasnas and ruchis of jeevatmas). The question of whether feeling sorrow for the suffering jeevatma will bring dosha to Bhagawan was answered in the first part.

Sri Sudarshana Suri defines karunyam as “स्वार्थ निरपेक्ष परदुख असहिष्णुता”.

The efforts of Bhagwan to bring jeevatmas and the continuous refusal of jeevatmas is very well presented in a Tirumanjan kattiyam of Sriman Parashara Bhattar, the illustrious son of Kureshacharya Swami, and the leader of the sampradaya after Sri Ramanujacharya. Tirumanjan refers to the divine bath of Bhagwan. In olden days, when someone had to take an oath, he would enter the river, raise both hands, and declare his words. Namperumal (Utsava murti of Bhagwan) was having tirumanjan and Sri Bhattar got the anubhavam as if Bhagwan is dipped in water, raising his both and declaring that the jeevatma belongs to me. The jeevatma is quick to refuse and declare that I belong to myself. He cites two arguments: anaadi-siddhaat, anubhava-vibhavaat. Let’s tell it Pre-conditioning and Sensation in English. From anaadi births and since childhood in this birth, we have conditioned that I belong to myself and that life is all about vishayaanubhavam. In sensation, jeevatma gets temporary pleasures and he is working with animal consciousness to avhieve that.

त्वं मेऽहं मे कुतस्तत् तदपि कुत इदं वेदमूलप्रमाणत्
एतच्चानादिसिद्धात् अनुभवविभवात् तर्हि साक्रोश एव ।
क्वाक्रोशः कस्य गीतदिषु मम विदितः कोऽत्र साक्षी सुधीः स्यात्
हन्त त्वत्पक्षपाति स इति नृकलहे मृग्यम्ध्यस्थवत् त्वम्॥

Paramatma – tvam me  –  I am your master. I own you.
Jeevatma – aham me – I am my own master
Paramatma – kuthastath – How do you claim that?
Jeevatma – tadhapi kutha – How do you claim that then?
Paramatma – idham veda moola pramaNaath  – This is has been established in the Vedas
Jeevatma – yethacchaanaadhisiddhaath anubhavavibhavaath – I speak from my own experience from the begin of time
Paramatma – tarhi saakrosha yeva – But it is discarded as not true
Jeevatma – kvaakroshaha kasya – by whom and when?
Paramatma – Githaadheeshu mama vidhithaha – In Bhagavad Gita, I myself have said that
Jeevatma – ko athra saakshee – Who is the witness for that?
Paramatma – sudhee syaath – The wise men
Jeevatma – hantha tvath pakshapaathee – They are all on your side. They are partial to you.

sa ithi nrukalahE mrugyamadhyasThavath tvam – Thus, the debate between the Jeevatma and Paramatma continued.

https://anecdotevault.wordpress.com/tag/parasara-bhattar/

Let’s see some questions:

Q. From Vaishnava philosophy, we learn that Sri Bhagwan is compassionate and omnipotent, and that He didn’t create this anadi samsara (it just existed anadi). Then why does not He stop, liquidate this terrible project of beginningless suffering for billions and billions of jivas, this anadi samsara?

Answer: Samsara is not a world where jeevas are kept to torment them. Samsara is created because Jeevas have always been vimukha to bhagwan. It’s not that jeevas have been kept in Samsara, but Samsara has evolved to accommodate the jeevas vimukha to Bhagwan. It’s not that Bhagwan created this anadi samsara. Since anaadi kaala, jeeva has been vimukha to bhagwan, so, samsara is created for them to enjoy the fruits of their desires and cultivate them on the right path. He wants the jeevas to be abhimukha to him, so he is trying to liquidate the mindset of the jeevatma.

Q: If Bhagavān were able to empathise with material suffering, then He would be compassionate to the people in the material world, and everyone would have stopped suffering because Bhagavān is fully capable of all action. Because he has no experience of suffering, however, he does not become compassionate. Bhagavān’s sphere of interaction is only with devotees, and His every action is for their sake alone. He has no interest in dealings in the material world, and this has been the case since beginningless time.

Reply: Sita says in Sundarkandam that the greatest gunam is Kaarunyam (Compassion) in 5.38.41. (आनृशंस्यं परो धर्मस्तवत्त्त ऐव मया श्रुतः।). कारुण्यं परदुखासहत्वं|

The material suffering of a jeevatma is due to their own karma. Every act of karma has to bear fruit. However, the compassion of Bhagwan is instrumental in saving the jeevatmas from the samsara and attaining the eternal service of Bhagwan. If the sphere of interaction of Bhagawan was towards his devotees only, there would not have been the creation itself in the first place. What punya or austerity have the Jeevatmas done so that Bhagwan should give him the great wealth of body, senses, etc.? This only proves that the karuna of Bhagwan is causeless, and it showers on jeevatma without any efforts from their end. It’s because of the sankalpam of bhagwan to lequidate the mindset of jeevatma that he created the samsara.

If so, why does not everyone get moksha? Why is someone a bhakta and someone a materialist? If Bhagwan is satya-sankalpa and bhagwan has made sankalpa to get every jeevatmas, how are there still baddh-jeevatmas?

Bhagwan karuna is for everyone, like rain showers equally on every field, but the output of the crop is dependent on the quality of the seed. The seend in the context of the jeevatmas is their karma. Due to karma (paap punya rupa karma), the jeevatma’s prakriti sambandham and hence avidya have covered the gyaanam of a jeevatma. It doesn’t realise that it is paratantra to Bhagwan and unless that knowledge develops, and jeevatma develops a strong desire to attain Bhagwan, the jeevatma suffers in samsaram.

Yes, Bhagwan is Satya-sankalpa. His Sankalpam is to achieve the jeevatma with his wish to attain him. If he wishes Vishaya bhogams, he gets them from Bhagwan, as per their karma.

Q. So, if everything is as per Karma of the jeevatma only, how can we say that the bhagwaan is the rakshaka (saviour)?

Reply: The karma of a jeevatma is just a vyaaja. Let’s understand it with a few examples:

कथञ्चिदुपकारेण कृतेनैकेन तुष्यति। न स्मरत्यपकाराणां शतमप्यात्मवत्तया।।2.1.11।।

Gifted with selfrestraint, Rama was pleased even with a single benefit done somehow to him, yet did not remember even a hundred offences committed by others.

Here, the word ‘kathanchit’ (even with, somehow) is very important. Bhagwan cannot leave such arrogant people, who are vimukha to bhagwan and hence he keeps trying to reform them. Jeevatma realises his swarupam when gets sattva gunam. He gets sattva gunam when he stores some punyam. But it is a matter of regret that even the required amount of Punyam for improvement is probably not found in them. Even in such a situation, God does not get disheartened, but he takes their random act as Punyam and grants them sattva-gunam and gyaanam. What’s Punyam and Paapam? The pleasure of bhagwan is Punyam and displeasure of Bhagwan is Paapam.

Our purvaacharyas have quoted a number of stories from the shastras:

A thief who always goes after people to pick their pockets would have entered God’s temple with someone with money, when God would believe that he is my devotee coming to my temple.
Or, while running after the cow that was running in fear to kill the cow grazing in his field, a killer might suddenly wander around a temple, to which God would interpret that this is the Mahatma who is circling around me (doing pradakdhina).
Or, a God-hating atheist might have slandered God by taking the name of God, or while calling his friends and friends, he might have chanted the name of God, like Ajamil, seeing which God would have believed that he is a saint who chants my name.
Or, while counting the ordinary mountains, along with the other mountains, Sheshadri, Sinhadri, Yadavadri etc. will also be counted, and then God will say that this is a saint who takes the name of my residence.

Or, a miser who never does charity would plant garlic, chard, etc. in his fields and would draw water from a distant well with the help of a machine, and at that time some Mahatmas travelling on that route, fed up with the heat, would water the water. While searching, seeing that water, he must have been a little happy after washing his hands and feet in it, seeing which God would understand that he is a great man who removes the sorrows of my devotees.

Or, some cunning people, engaged in vices like gambling, adultery, etc., might have kept a secluded house suitable for their misdeeds on the outskirts of the village. During the rainy season, some devotees travelling on a journey might have suddenly come and rested for a night, due to which the Lord would wake up with the same interest, saying, Oh! What a favour he did for my devotees!

Ramanuja tells in Sri Bhashya, “यथा अयं आत्मानम् प्राप्नोति, तथा भगवान स्वमेव प्रयतत

Meaning: As we take effort on our own to reach our dear ones, similarly, Bhagwaan himself chooses to deliver us by his own efforts at the appropriate time. 

Sri Sudarshan Suri says, “पुण्यक्षेत्रादिषु भगवतः प्रीति: स्वस्मिन् प्रीतिमत् पुरुष वरणार्था”| Bhagwan is stationed in divya desas, only to choose the persons who have love towards them.

vaatsalyam

Like a cow licks the dirt of calf and removes her dirt, makes her clean and accepts her, bhagwan also makes us clean, removes prakriti-sambandha, avidya, develops paratantrya gyaanam in us and then accept us by declaring that the jeevatma has surrendered to me.

Swami Alvandar says that the jeevatma is your property, so how can I do aatma-samaprpanam? It was possible if the aatma was my property and I was surrendering to him with my own independance/free will. But, jeevatma is bhagwaan’s property, dependant on him and it was his efforts through millions of births that jeevatma got prified (Like the calf) and develops swarupa gyaanam and thus accepts Bhagwan as both means and refuse and thus attain him.

If someone says that I attained bhagwan through gyaana or Bhakti or Karma, isn’t is being ungrateful? If someone says that Bhagwan showed kaarunyam to me as I was qualified for it, isn’t that highly ungrateful?

Yes, it is, going by the discussion above. Even a jeevatma having adwesha (no opposition/hatred) towards bhagwan, that itself is due to the efforts of Bhagwan. If a jeevatma is having opposition/hatred towards bhagwan, that means that the stubborn jeevatma have not yet received the kaarunyam of Bhagwan.